“Bait shop that hides the best fish tacos on the marina — pick your catch, order at the counter, eat with a view.”
Reviewers note you have to look for it — 'all you see is a bait shop' on the main side, restaurant entrance is around the corner on the east side.
One reviewer specifically praises that tacos aren't generic 'fish tacos' but let you 'choose your fish variety' — suggests daily catch flexibility.
Reviewer mentions 'the line moves quickly' — indicates order-at-counter setup despite higher-than-typical fish taco pricing.
Google summary explicitly states 'mostly locally caught fish' and freshness is praised in multiple reviews ('super fresh,' specific species like spiny lobster and wahoo).
Google summary places it 'sitting quaintly on the marina' and reviewer confirms 'view is perfect' after whale watching.
“Mitch's Seafood is Point Loma's answer to the eternal question: what's the freshest fish we can eat without owning a boat?”
While Shanghai Bun traffics in soup dumplings and dim sum rituals, Mitch's deals in a completely different currency: whatever the local boats hauled in this morning. This is the spot where proximity to the marina isn't just atmosphere—it's the supply chain. The seafood here is so local that regulars joke you could've waved at your lunch while it was still swimming.
The setup is deceptively humble—tucked next to a bait shop on the marina, easy to miss unless you're looking for it. But that low profile is part of the appeal. Once you find it, you're ordering at a counter, claiming a table on the patio, and watching boats drift past while you wait. The fish tacos aren't your standard beer-battered beach fare; you choose your fish—wahoo, mahi, yellowtail—and they grill it to order. That choice matters when the difference between yesterday's catch and today's is the difference between good and exceptional.
The spiny lobster shows up seasonally and draws a devoted following—sweet, perfectly cooked, the kind of thing people come back for twice in one weekend. The chowder runs peppery and loaded with actual seafood, not filler. Lemonade's house-made and surprisingly memorable, which feels right for a place that doesn't do shortcuts.
Expect a line—it moves, but weekends and post-beach crowds stack up fast. Parking's marina-adjacent, meaning it's either wide open or a slow lap around the lot depending on the hour. Prices lean higher than your average taco counter, but you're paying for fish that was swimming this morning, not sitting in a truck. That's the trade, and for most regulars, it's worth it.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience.
Restaurants · Little Italy · $$$
“A seafood restaurant that actually respects its fish”
$$$Restaurants · Point Loma · $$
“San Diego's best food hall in a converted Navy training center at Liberty Station”
$$Point Loma · Ice Cream & Dessert
Follow a savory seafood dinner with a sweet treat at this close-by creamery for a perfect dessert capstone to your meal.
Shelter Island · Venue
After enjoying fresh seafood, transition to casual beers and outdoor vibes at this nearby waterfront biergarten for a relaxed evening continuation.
1403 Scott St, San Diego, CA 92106, USA
3 months ago