ExtraMile

While most convenience stores in La Jolla are afterthoughts attached to service stations, ExtraMile actually runs a loyalty program that pays off — free chips on signup, rotating deals that matter if you're stopping here regularly. It's the difference between a place that wants your repeat business and one that just wants your credit card swipe.

This is the go-to spot for locals who need more than gas. The coffee setup is legitimate enough for a pre-surf morning run, and the selection runs deeper than the usual convenience store suspects. You're not getting craft provisions or farmers market finds, but you're also not paying village markup on basics.

Breana (mentioned by name in multiple reviews) seems to be the reason people return beyond the rewards — consistent service matters more than you'd think when you're just trying to grab what you need and get on with your day. The 5-star rating from only four reviews is unusual for a gas station, but it tracks when the staff actually knows regulars.

Parking flows better here than at some of the cramped stations closer to Prospect Street, and delivery service means you can skip the trip entirely if you're below the bluff and just need essentials sent down. Not every La Jolla errand requires a production — sometimes you just need a functional spot that doesn't waste your time.