
“La Jolla's time capsule: live piano, red-sauce soul, and enough butter to make your cardiologist nervous.”
One reviewer specifically noted 'extremely buttery and greasy' cooking, even the broccoli.
Guests dressed up, reviewer felt Crocs were out of place — this isn't casual.
Piano player performs around 7pm, multiple reviews mention live music and singing as defining feature.
Dark vintage decor described as 'straight out of an old-school Manhattan restaurant,' not beachy La Jolla.
“Manhattan Of La Jolla recreates the old-school Manhattan steakhouse experience — live piano, dark wood, tableside service — in a village known for its ocean views and California casual.”
While most La Jolla restaurants capitalize on the coastline, Manhattan runs the opposite direction: mahogany paneling, white tablecloths, and a piano bar that could've been lifted from a 1960s supper club. It's the only spot below the bluff where you'll see sport coats and heels on a regular Tuesday, and where the lighting is deliberately dim enough to feel like evening regardless of the marine layer outside.
The Italian-American menu follows suit — veal piccata, osso buco, Dover sole prepared tableside. Chef Toney runs a kitchen that favors richness over restraint; dishes arrive heavy on butter and cream, which is either exactly what you want or a problem depending on your appetite. The Manhattan (yes, they serve a dish named after themselves) is the signature order, though regulars also go for the veal.
Live piano starts around 7pm most nights, and the bar area fills quickly with a crowd that knows the words to standards. If you're planning dinner, request the bar side for the music — the dining room feels formal by comparison. Reservations are essential on weekends, and the Saturday night scene runs late by village standards.
Parking is street-only along Fay Avenue; arrive 10 minutes early to circle. Weekend evenings after 6pm bring a wait even with reservations, especially when the piano player draws a following. The Crocs review is real — this is not a flip-flops-and-board-shorts kind of place.
Downside: the food skews rich. If you're sensitive to butter or prefer lighter preparations, order carefully or skip it entirely. The atmosphere is the draw here — if you want a night that feels transported from another era, with live jazz and tableside flourishes, Manhattan delivers. If you want coastal and vegetable-forward, Trilogy is three blocks away.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience.
Restaurants · Little Italy · $$$$
“San Diego's most theatrical steakhouse”
$$$$Restaurants · South Park · $$
“The Neapolitan pizza that South Park was waiting for”
$$Restaurants · La Jolla · $$$$
“Three levels, three concepts, one spectacular ocean view”
$$$$La Jolla · Venue
Le Coq provides French bistro elegance as a sophisticated nightcap destination after a classic Manhattan steakhouse dinner, both upscale but distinct cuisines.
La Jolla · Sushi
TAKARAMONO SUSHI offers Japanese cuisine as a complementary contrast to Manhattan of La Jolla's American steakhouse fare, perfect for a progressive dining experience in the same neighborhood.
7766 Fay Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA
a year ago