
“Navy SEAL-founded Coronado pub where the shepherd's pie beats the nachos and the vibe runs on pride, not gimmicks.”
Orange Avenue pub with regulars and military community — not a tourist trap despite proximity to Hotel del Coronado.
Founded by a Navy SEAL Corpsman, still frequented by SEALs — the military lineage is the heartbeat here.
"Amazing people who love what they do and are proud of this establishment" — the service energy matters here.
Multiple reviews cite it specifically — "was great," "flavor was good" — the Irish dishes outperform the generic bar menu.
“McP's Irish Pub is where Navy SEALs and island families both end up on a Tuesday night, drawn by the same shepherd's pie that's outlasted base closures and bridge traffic.”
What separates McP's from every other pub claiming Irish heritage is its actual lineage — founded by a Navy SEAL Corpsman, this spot earned its Coronado bones before it poured its first Guinness. You're not getting theme-park Ireland here; you're getting the kind of bar where active-duty guys in civvies sit three stools down from retirees who remember when Orange Avenue had fewer tourists, all of them ordering the same shepherd's pie that shows up in reviews like clockwork.
The Irish dishes — shepherd's pie, fish and chips — consistently outperform the standard bar fare, which tells you what the kitchen cares about. That shepherd's pie comes properly seasoned, not the bland hotel-banquet version, and they'll split it for two with enough on each plate to justify the modest upcharge. The rest of the menu exists to fill gaps, not win awards, but when you're this close to the ferry landing and open late, nobody's asking for molecular gastronomy.
The draw is atmosphere over execution — dark wood, memorabilia that means something to the locals who left it there, the kind of corner-booth privacy that works whether you're celebrating a promotion or debriefing a bad day. Service leans friendly without the forced cheerfulness that plagues tourist traps; staff treat regulars and first-timers with the same no-nonsense warmth.
Parking on Orange Avenue is its own contact sport, especially summer weekends — the municipal lot behind Village Theater is your best bet. Come for an early dinner before the late-night crowd rolls in, or embrace the chaos after 9pm when the patio fills with people who've earned their beer. Either way, you're walking into a place that's been here long enough to stop trying to be anything other than what it is.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience.
Venue · Coronado · $
Venue · Coronado · $
Venue · Coronado · $$
Coronado · Venue
Villa Nueva Bakery works as a morning-after or pre-pub coffee and pastry stop, creating a full-day neighborhood experience that bookends a night out.
Coronado · Venue
Gelato Paradiso provides a sweet, casual dessert destination to cap off an evening at the pub, offering complementary post-dinner indulgence within walking distance.
1107 Orange Ave, Coronado, CA 92118, USA
5 months ago